Considering the predictive power,
and corresponding new insights, that a research study will provide is a more
meaningful measure of its rigor and value than what particular research design
it uses. Currently, this stimulating idea came into me. This way of evaluating
and judging the value of a given research based on whether one can use the
results to predict the possibilities of the occurrence of something is quite
new to me, as my preconceived opinion on the value of a research narrowly lies
in whether some high-level, complicated or cutting-edge or profound methods and
approach have been used during the course of research, from the designing
section to the data collecting and interpretations. It changed my knowledge
upon how to assess an article, enabling me to ask myself questions while
reading, for instance, Does the article provide me with enough information to
duplicate the research?, What meaningful measurable outcomes could be
predicted?, What is the significance and contribution (new insights)to the given
field? and so on. Summing up, this stimulating perspective has broaden my mind
during the reading and criticizing an article into a more holistic way, I do
not feel that I am new to a discipline and do not have enough knowledge to make
judgments of other’s work, especially when the work is of some well-known
author and when it comes to evaluating the article’s contribution.
No comments:
Post a Comment